Minty Fresh vs Sensitive Natural Toothpaste: Which Suits Your Teeth?
By Grants of Australia | Australian made natural toothpaste | Published: 2026-10-13
Category: Comparisons
Compare Grants Fresh Mint and Sensitive Natural Toothpaste on sensitivity, flavour, and ingredients. Find out which one fits your daily brushing routine.
Quick answer
If your teeth or gums sting when you brush or you notice bleeding, choose Grants Sensitive Natural Toothpaste because it contains Potassium Nitrate to relieve gum sensitivity and help bleeding gums. If your main goal is long-lasting fresh breath and you have no sensitivity, Grants Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste delivers a strong minty taste with organic tea tree oil. Both are fluoride-free and SLS-free, so the deciding factor is whether you need sensitivity relief or a bolder mint hit.
How the two toothpastes differ in practice
Grants Sensitive Natural Toothpaste is built around Potassium Nitrate, a mild ingredient that works on nerve comfort to relieve gum sensitivity and help bleeding gums. It is fluoride-free and SLS-free, so it will not foam as much as a conventional paste. That lower foam is normal for SLS-free formulas and does not mean it is cleaning less. Grants Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste takes a different route: it uses organic tea tree oil and a strong minty taste for fresh breath. It is also vegan, SLS-free, and fluoride-free. Neither paste contains fluoride, so if your dentist has told you that you need fluoride for cavity prevention, talk to them before switching. For everyone else, the choice comes down to whether sensitivity or breath freshness is your priority.
What to expect when you switch to a natural, SLS-free paste
Both toothpastes skip SLS, the detergent that creates thick foam in many mainstream products. You may notice less lather and a different mouthfeel for the first week. That is not a sign the paste is failing. Brush for the full two minutes and rinse gently. If you are moving from a sensitive-specific toothpaste that contains potassium nitrate or stannous fluoride, give the Grants Sensitive option a fair trial for at least two weeks before deciding it is not for you. For the Fresh Mint paste, the organic tea tree oil gives a slightly medicinal edge behind the mint. Some people love it; others prefer a simpler mint. If you are unsure, start with the smaller size or use it as your morning paste and keep a sensitive paste for evenings.
Flavour strength and daily routine fit
The Fresh Mint paste is the stronger mint of the two. That makes it a good match if you drink coffee or tea and want a clean, sharp finish before meetings or bed. The Sensitive paste is milder in taste because its focus is comfort, not a flavour punch. If you have ever found strong mint toothpaste irritating to your gums or the roof of your mouth, the Sensitive version is the safer daily choice. You can also pair either paste with Grants Minty Fresh Natural Mouthwash, which is alcohol-free and made with Xylitol to help prevent decay. The mouthwash is a good oral rinse for sensitive teeth and gums, so it works alongside both pastes without adding burn. Using a mouthwash does not replace brushing, but it can help reach areas your brush misses.
Trade-offs to weigh before you choose
- Sensitivity relief vs breath intensity: The Sensitive paste prioritises gum comfort with Potassium Nitrate, while the Fresh Mint paste prioritises a strong minty taste with organic tea tree oil. You are trading a bolder flavour for targeted sensitivity support, or the other way around. If you have bleeding gums or twinges, comfort wins. If your breath is the main concern, choose Fresh Mint.
- Fluoride-free and SLS-free for both: Neither toothpaste contains fluoride or SLS. That means no cavity-prevention fluoride and less foam than a conventional paste. If your dentist has recommended fluoride, these are not a direct swap. Confirm with your dentist if you need fluoride before making either paste your only toothpaste.
- Mild taste vs strong mint: The Sensitive paste is mild, which suits people who find strong mint irritating. The Fresh Mint paste is deliberately strong, which suits people who want a sharp clean after meals. Match the flavour strength to your tolerance, not to what someone else recommends.
Product facts at a glance
- Sensitive Natural Toothpaste: Grants Sensitive Natural Toothpaste is mild, fluoride-free, SLS-free, and contains Potassium Nitrate to relieve gum sensitivity and help bleeding gums. This is the targeted choice if you feel twinges when brushing or notice blood on your brush. The potassium nitrate addresses comfort rather than just flavour.
- Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste: Grants Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste contains organic tea tree oil and has a strong minty taste for fresh breath. It is vegan, SLS-free, and fluoride-free. Pick this one when breath freshness is the goal and you do not have ongoing sensitivity. The tea tree oil adds an antibacterial-style clean, while the strong mint lingers.
- Minty Fresh Natural Mouthwash: Grants Minty Fresh Natural Mouthwash is a good oral rinse for sensitive teeth and gums. It is alcohol-free and made with natural ingredients and Xylitol to prevent decay. Use it after brushing with either paste to reach tight spots without the sting of alcohol. The Xylitol adds a decay-prevention step that neither toothpaste claims on its own.
Which one fits you?
Best for
- People with sensitive teeth or gums who want a mild, fluoride-free, SLS-free paste with Potassium Nitrate
- Anyone who notices bleeding gums when brushing and wants a gentler daily formula
- Shoppers who prefer a mild taste over a strong mint blast
Not for
- People whose dentist has told them they need fluoride for cavity prevention
- Anyone who wants the strongest possible mint flavour and no sensitivity concerns
- Shoppers looking for a foaming toothpaste, since both are SLS-free
